The Byzantine Generals Message (Me Troglor)

With covid-19 upon us, I suggest that we have now passed a point where we will be forced to move forwards into a very different world and the ships which we had previously been aboard are now both in flames and sinking into the ocean.

As a novice Joyce scholar and avid fan of “Finnegans Wake”, the mundane stream of our lives has been jarringly interrupted by a massive thunder-strike.  Joyce captures the first of these on page one of the wake with the word:


As each of the ten thunder-words appears in the story, the world changes.  This is in accord with the thinking of a Giambattisto Vico who promoted a cyclical view of history in his work “The New Science”.   Briefly, Vico sees a repeating cycle of three ages: the divine, the heroic, and the human.  Or differently stated: the age of religion, the age of reason, and the final age of the secular.  Although it might seem that we have been dwelling in the age of religion, Dr. Charles Taylor is correct in labeling the age of our lifetime as “The Secular Age”, but as I say, the Thunder has struck and and in the Wake, the cycle begins again.  Certainly Donald Trump would have us believe that we are now in a new age, and we are, and we now have the choice to live as wards of a Rentier police state in violence, or to take control ourselves of the tools of our liberation and create new systems and orders.  This is real meaning of a modern age of religion, the act as a group guided by our better angels and to cast out the charlatans and idle holders of our debt.

I believe that we have been long overdue for a bit of change in the world and that such things don’t happen gradually, but instead quite suddenly.

Our world is quite broken in almost every way imaginable, and had been before Donald Trump and certainly before this current global pandemic.  Most struggle and a few are able to maintain some sort of respectable middle class existence at the cost of a life filled with fear of falling from falling into obscurity.

It is from this perspective that I present the above tiny financial transaction.  I etched this into the dogecoin blockchain with a system that I have spent the last year devising.  I have done so without any sponsors and at great personal and financial sacrifice.  The transaction can be read on the following website:


or on this website:


or this website:


or on one of one hundred other similar “blockchain explorers” or by downloading and running your own instance of dogecoind which you can inspect yourself and compile from source code if you wish:


You are free to create your own currency and implement this sort of message system, or use litecoin, or bitcoin, or zcash, or any of the many other altcoins already running.

You can use various clients on your phone or computer to access the system without needing to register or pay any sort of fee to a gatekeeper.

My point is that this system is wildly free and opened and outside of the control of any central authority.  If all of the resources mentioned above were blocked or taken offline, the blockchain would not be stopped and the message can not be removed by anyone, ever.

This is to me the perfect language system which Joyce envisioned in the Wake, and it is something than can have countless beautiful interfaces wrapped around, but ultimately at its core, it will just run.

So onto the actual message.  First of all, the message posted in seconds and the fee paid to the miners was 10 dogecoin.  At a cost of one dogecoin for $0.002  this message costs about two or three pennies.  The message identifies its sender in two ways as myself and I still have access to the accounts which it references:


By using any of the block explorer above, you can drill and spin through these accounts to see other readable messages such as one that references my LLC: Secret Beach Solutions.

The idea of “Byzantine Generals” is a reference to the Byzantine Fault   problem which Satoshi Nakamoto solved in the now-famous Bitcoin Whitepaper.

The irony is of course that the message is now secret in how it is presented, but is presented via a system which is build on proof-of-work and allows players who otherwise can’t trust each other to work together and understand that their communications are not compromised by agents in the very village which they hope to sack.

The message is presented in two forms, the first being a bash script which by relatively trivial processes can always be reduced to the three numbers seen embedded in the transaction itself.  Anyone knowing the system could work backwards from the blockchain post to reveal the bash script, regenerate the numbers, and understand the entire message.  The use of random capitalization in the message however makes this mathematically quite difficult.  Also the script could contain lines that are dropped from the message on purpose and even could contain elements that could be executed and complete some task, like firing up an entire cloud instance of dogecoin.

Well that’s it for now, fellow generals, if you are interested in this, then download a dogecoin client and send me an address that gets generated when you “request currency”.



Readable cryptocurrency transactions and financial auditing

I have created a very simply system of cryptocurrency transactions using a format which is called “scriptless script” (or perhaps scryptless scrypt).  I believe that the system has great potential for finance and law because it is possible to create a contract that puts human-readability as its first priority.  The system bundles together many special addresses (see the link at the end of the post) in order to create a transaction that can do three things:

  1. Contain a financial transaction in the given currency, sending money to one or more users/servers.
  2. Contain a very large set of readable text which is rendered in a somewhat odd looking (fermented) format.
  3. Contain references to unix or linux computer scripts which can be shared off-line and verified with great ease and certainly to be what is reference in the transaction.

Lately, I have worked on the readability of this system.  Although this example doesn’t deal directly with money, the system is so generally powerful and readable that users can adapt it to their specific cases pretty easily.

First, I create a bash function which (in this case) doesn’t execute any actual commands:

thats.great () 
    : it started with an;
    : earthquake;
    : bird and snakes;
    : and airplanes;
    : and lenny bruce;
    : is not afraid

Without needing to deeply understand bash, one can see that this appears to be a phrase starting with the words “That’s Great”.  The rest of the function refers to an REM song which was popular when I was young.

I store these functions in single files which follow a very specific naming-convention:


The numbers in the function’s name are generated from its contents in a way that is similar to how cryptocurrency addresses are formed, so the function and file can be seen as a sort of secret.  In this case we will describe the function in a transaction with the lines:


The first line always begins with the letters “DCx” to mean Dimecash, subsequent lines always start with the number 9 followed by a small letter s-z.  In order to put this message on the blockchain, each of these unspendable addresses needs to be sent some currency.  In dogecoin, this is a very cheap process and the specific amount of currency sent can have very special meanings.  Here is the actual command that was used to send the message above:

dogecoin-cli sendmany “” “{\

By using html emphasis, we are able to more easily read the message, while at the same time seeing an actual command that can be used to rebroadcast it.

dogecoin-cli sendmany “” “{\

Note that in addition to the readable message, the codes 5467, 9585684, and 452 are also included.  This acts as a sort of key which can be used remotely to reference the message.

The message does not credit REM as its author, and contains at least one typographical error (bird should be birds).  Regardless of these sort-comings, it has been written into the dogecoin ledger and (like all ledger transactions) can not be removed or altered.  This is very powerful.  Consider the potential of a system like this for communication and identity verification after checking out the messages as it shows up on this remote ledger:

By keeping track of transaction ids and using specialized block explorers, we are easily able to find all of the readable transaction on dogecoin that start with “DCx” and follow the other idiosyncratic aspects of the system.

In the wake of COVID-19, I suggest that this system can be used for highly readable financial transactions as well as for an emergency broadcasting system.  The system doesn’t use particularly sophisticated software, is completely open-sourced, and doesn’t need the buy-in of a development team or currency “owner” in order to be implemented.  This means that people could ramp up to use this very quickly.


Obviously Unspendable Cryptocurrency Addresses

Blockchain solutions generally come in two forms:

  1. Proof-of-work systems which allow participants to join or leave at will without any sort of registration process. I call these “public”.
  2. Proof-of-stake systems which are restricted to certain members who are invited to participate.  O call these “private”.

Bitcoin (and the alt-coins which are derived from it are “public”.  My work has been with the specific altcoin which is named “dogecoin” because it is relatively stable, seems to have an interesting user base, and is very inexpensive.

I will thus be speaking about dogecoin specifically, but the main topic (obviously unspendable addresses) applies to many similar currencies (including bitcoin).

When someone downloads a cryptocurrency “wallet” to their phone or computer, a few addresses are created and assigned to them.  By sharing these addresses with others, the currency can come to life with immediate person-to-person transactions.  No bank, mint, or intermediary is a part of this transaction (although some core dogecoin server will “win” the right to craft the transaction into the next block of the chain.  This server will be rewarded with some newly created currency and some mining fees.  These servers, like all of the users, are not part of any organization other than perhaps mining pools.  This is all necessary to keep from having to have a central authority put in place to act as a gate-keeper.

One of the most striking oddities of this system is that the addresses which are used don’t have readable names and are calculated from secret keys which can be generated in a trivial way.

Here are some examples of what these addresses look like in dogecoin:


Notice that although each address starts with the letter “D”, the rest appears to be a random mixture of letters and numbers.  Each of the addresses above has a private key which the owner’s wallet keeps as a secret.

It is possible to short-circuit the address creation process and create an address that is quite readable, but has no known private key.  Examples are:


Any currency sent to these addresses will be lost, and can actually be considered to be “burned” or destroyed.  This is the foundation of a process known as proof-of-burn.   These addresses are also called “obviously unspendable” because it is mathematically improbability that they were calculated in the way that normal “spendable” addresses would be.

These addresses create the cornerstone for the communication system that I promote and can be created with the python script:





The ‘It might as well be you’ broadcast

Today, I sent out a bunch of tweets to magazines, universities, newspapers, and anybody else that I could think of that might be interested in this project. Hopefully some of you are here because of that effort.

In each tweet, I included a compound unspendable message, where the greeting and closing were unique, but the body was the same in every case:

DCxDEARxCoiNDESKzzzzzzzzzzzzarJyuK <-- unique DCxHELLovxHoWxARExYoUkzzzzzzRc7Dgf DCxixAMxDoiNGxWELLhzzzzzzzzzU7w1d6 DCxTHANKSxFoRxASKiNGhzzzzzzzWu5KQh DCxixWoULDxLiKExFoRxYoUxTozzWq5WCs DCxPUBLiSHxANxARTiCLExABoUTzVzGB1i DCxHTTPSwffDiMEhCASHzzzzzzzzYqAXa2 DCxTHExSYSTEMxPRESENTSxAzzzzWvbSP9 DCxRADiCALLYxNEWxWAYxFoRzzzzYrtt3y DCxPEoPLExToxUSExCRYPTohzzzzUBScy7 DCxSoMEoNExNEEDSxToxBREAKzzzXue5ur DCxTHiSxSToRYvxANDxiTxMiGHTzaKLnAj DCxASxWELLxBExYoUhxHUGSxANDzRLuY2d DCxKiSSESvxFoREVERxYoURxFANzWqVcQb DCxCAPTAiNxEUGENExSToRMYPANTS8JjZ6 <-- unique By searching on one of the middle lines, you can access all of the other messages in the set: The address shows up 38 times and the page contains a list showing each recipient of the message. The result is that each message can be reduced to a unique code (called Satoshi code on this site) and all of the messages share a large common middle. Each line, starting with DCxHELLovxHoWxARExYoUkzzzzzzRc7Dgf and ending with DCxKiSSESvxFoREVERxYoURxFANzWqVcQb is therefore comprised of addresses which are all shared and thus easy to connect on a ledger. Therefore, the whole set of Satoshi codes can be seen as a reference to the whole. With some work, an explorer could find all of the message recipients and calculate their five-digit codes. Of course, we can do this for you on the site and create a list of all the codes. Each code is shown in the Doge Ledger. This system can become a specific payment system, so that if any of the organizations decide to make a donation to this site (or someone makes a donation on their behalf) that information would be captures. An example code is 49285 for the message above: => cat DCxDEARxCoiNDESKzzzzzzzzzzzzarJyuK.txt (unix command to show contents of file)
=> cat DCxDEARxCoiNDESKzzzzzzzzzzzzarJyuK.txt | sum (the same command piped into a very simple checksum (which is like a weak hash)
49285 1

This also appears on the Ledger page of this site. Therefore, if you wanted to make a special payment with a message added which would (barring no more reasonable meaning) be a reference to the above code, then you could end your transactions as .00049285. In this case, Dogecoin is perfectly suited to represent this information in this way because of the balance between its price, stability, and relative popularity. This is all very abstract at this point, and so I will be working on more systems to simplify these, so that someone could pull pick their favorite college, magazine or other entry from a mass mailing such as the one I sent today and quickly send a donation which would include a coded message. This would be like the sample color test, but would be an actual transfer of funds to a real address whose meaning could be interpreted.

Specifically, given today’s XDC price, you could use the following math to make a $50 pledge that imples the above message and thus Coindesk:

$50 USD = 24,570.0246 Dogecoin
24570.00000000 is also $50.00
adding code:
This pattern naturally occurs in less than .1% of the transactions when
other digits appear to the right.

A 24570.00049285 payment to D8yMyFxAn3WSbvqm8eHVVUK53xBLAh6V61 would come to me and I would look for a meaning to go with the last eight digits. The transaction is statically quite rare with the three zeroes in the middle and could also be remotely audited, so a third party could come to understand that $50 was perhaps tagged with a special meaning, though they wouldn’t know what it was unless they pulled down a bunch of likely transactions and began calculations. This isn’t as far-fetches as one might imagine and created an fully functional system which included text, calculation, disclosure, and transfer of funds that can go right from one phone to another.

Over time, and with context (such as a consistent target address), these codes could come to have very specific meanings which could be calculated from the ledger. If you
feel like you want to make a donation today, then please visit the Donation page. If you are interested in learning more about this project, please call or text 682-666-0614 or send an email:, but sometimes email takes me a while.

So to summarize, just sending the messages out in this form-letter way, with shared addresses creates an entire set of meaning, and each message individually can be reduced to a code that could be included into a payment. The messages don’t ask for money, but in lieu of a more recent code which is tied to a message asking for money, one might assume that each payment is from (or as a reference to) the entity listed on the first line. It seems to me that these three systems together are quite powerful: unspendable addresses, CRC satoshi codes which resolve to the entire message, and the idea that a set of addresses can be connected by one or more shared lines.

The last piece in the system might be a timed message, such as sending out a daily transaction glossary at 11:32 GMT (a time of Wakean significance) each day. In order to remotely “see” all of the data of the system, someone would only need to browse to the block closest to 11:32 and look for a transmission. Much of this was covered in a public disclosure which came out almost 1 year ago and can be found on, so feel free to play with these ideas yourself, if you want to build your own, then let me know, though there are elements of this site that I intend to keep private and monetize and license out.



I finally got around to put this site behind WordPress

This project now has a consistently updated database from Dogecoin that is displayed in the directory. Basically, any address that starts with “DCx*” or “9*z” will show up here. If you want to add your own single lines into the ledger, you will need to download ‘unspendable’ from It is just a python script. For the large multi-line messages, you would need to form a sendmany. OK, that is it. Feel free to comment onto this post or shoot me an email: